Our Story

Name: Sandy's Pizza
Address: 609 South Main Street, Fort Branch, IN, 47648, US
Telephone: (812) 753-3972
Price range: $4.99 - $59.99

A Fun & Unique Dining Experience

Sandy’s Pizza started in 1975 in a small town north of Evansville, IN. We got our start in an old store building, with a rolling pin and a washtub. Today, in a modern new building, seating 170, we feature a large arrangement of advertising signage, mainly from the local area. We have a separate “Coke” room which seats up to 80 guests. Sandy’s Pizza is known for our support of the community, including schools, churches, and nonprofit organizations. After building our new building, it was destroyed three years later. With the help of over 128 volunteers, we were able to resume limited operations in nine days and were back to full production in 90 days. For this reason, Sandy’s Pizza is committed and dedicated to our community..

Google Rating

4.1

Sandy's Pizza

4.1

Nathaniel Showalter

05:54 14 Aug 23

I really like this place. They serve pretty good thin crust, pizza have their own style of root beer. The decor is interesting in itself and gives it a rather hometown feel. Five stars for uniqueness

JP Wilson

05:43 18 Jul 23

Great food, great times, amazing atmosphere, recently expanded beer menu(thank you) mom and pop vibe! DEFINITELY an experience. Basically a Coke museum. Also the daily lunch specials are delicious, filling, and a great deal at just $10 you get an entree two sides and a side salad, just $11.50 if you add a drink!! GREAT VALUE!

Robert Cooper

15:09 21 Jun 23

We made it an annual event told my son's birthday party at Sandy's and they have the 3-foot pizza

Jay Mason

21:37 10 Jun 23

Sandy's is where my wife and I came to 19 years ago on a date. We sat in the Elvis booth. The food was great and service was good and the atmosphere nice. We stopped in today it is the same wonderful experience we had 19 years ago. We loved the pizza and bread sticks.

Ron Tinsley

01:14 03 Jun 23

Tasty root beer on tap, pizza to order comes out hot and fresh, optional salad bar, decore is awesome country tin sigh theme, old collectable toys and rock music statues. Fun family experience!

Mark Worstell

12:30 20 May 23

A localized favorite. Not being from there, it is ok, it's pizza. They do have a unique sweet red pepper that is tasty that is added to several pizzas. It is decorated nicely. They have a special root beer on tap, unfortunately, it was out when we were there. Service was friendly, however we did have a couple mix ups on our party's order. One thing I hear from everyone in the region is that they want the salad bar back.

Dennis Wirth

03:18 18 May 23

Went on Mother's Day... There were only 2 people working. Large crowd, they were very stressed but they still got us handled and with a good attitude. Pizza was great and we tipped them really good for being short handed but making sure we were taken care of. I was impressed by them

Stacy N.

19:06 17 May 23

Great bunch that 💪 works here... they always get my orders the way I want them and courteous to get me a drink if I have to wait longer than they told me it would be . They get busy, and delivery can take longer at times, so I normally pick up my orders. It is almost a custom to get sweet red peppers on your pizza or Strom. I have been to a lot of pizza shops, and this little gem is awesome on its own!

mia wensley

02:42 12 Apr 23

Me and my softball team visited Sandy's after our game and we had a blast took many pictures with Elvis a statue in the booth service was amazing with our party of 17! definitely will be visiting again

David Adams

23:57 16 Jun 22

The sweet red peppers here are unlike anywhere else! Get the pizza, the pasta, anything with those sweet reds!

Lucille Marvell

17:31 02 Jun 22

Pizza was very delicious. Service good. Very accommodating.

Grumpy Cat

16:31 25 Apr 22

Nobody does pizza better than Sandy's. Hands down Sandy's Pizza is the best pizza in the tristate! The sweet red peppers are to die for!

Abbie H

12:44 03 Apr 22

Always a great experience at Sandy's. Love their pizzas & Stroms!! Very friendly customer service.

Rodney Groff

23:53 25 Mar 22

My wife and I ordered a medium combination pizza that was $10.49 and an order of cheesy bread sticks. The cheesy bread sticks came out quickly with 2 containers of cheese dip and one marinara, they were quite good, fresh. The mozzarella on the bread sticks was tasty. There was more than the 2 of us could eat. The combination pizza was great with all the flavors you'd want on a pizza: Olives, mushrooms, pepperoni, sausage, lots of cheese. The crust was just right, not to thin, not too thick. A big plus is that the drinks are free, self serve. We got out of there for less than $20 plus tip. This place is old, but it has a lot of great character, go check it out.

Christine Scheller

14:32 01 Feb 22

Ashley was our server-great job. Very attentive,food was hot and delicious. Definitely going back

Stephen Dill

10:08 01 Feb 22

I love their pizza customer service is great . You will love the root beer there

James Ankenbrand

00:48 03 Jan 22

This place is awesome. A definite must. Got to see the 36" pizza. Love the decor

Aaron Brown

20:08 02 Dec 21

They was a slight mix up on the order but they took care us while we were waiting. Everyone was so friendly we will be going back for sure.

Teeeve

20:38 22 Nov 21

I love the building, very unique. Service was good although can tell they are short handed. Food was good too. I would return.

Steve Dickey

04:37 11 Sep 21

Pizza, good stuff. Would eat here again. Definitely try the root beer on tap. Stromboli is very good. I really like the aesthetics of the place, really cool vibe. Bathrooms are clean and there is a changing table in a spot where moms or dads can access it and that really speaks to me.

Ally Patt

02:59 11 Sep 21

Tia was our server and was so kind and helpful. The pizza is awesome!! Also, the grinder sandwich is massive and delicious. 100% will be coming back for the food, vibes, and service. 13/10 🙌🙌🙌

kevin smeltzer

00:39 28 Aug 21

Server was great! Pizza was even better. Always a great time. We live 3 hours away and we are planning a trip just for Sandy's pizza.

Chris Stiles

13:50 08 Aug 21

Great place with lots of cool decor and delicious pizza and garlic bread!

Jacob Mounts

09:52 04 Aug 21

Sandy's has been a little on the pricy side for a long time but I've tolerated it because of the sweet red peppers they have, which is the best part of their pizza. However, it's starting to get to be a little too pricy. Including an hour drive each way back towards where I grew up just to get to the restaurant, granted I only stop by when I have other reasons to go back to that area, two large pizzas and an order of bread sticks was nearly $60. I love the pizza, but it's getting too expensive to order from them even if I lived around there still.

Todd Snyder

17:30 28 Jul 21

Always awesome! On my mist have list when visiting Southern Indiana

john elliott

11:43 07 Jun 21

Our first visit here, the pizza was great and the server Tia was even better. We will be a regular customer in the future.

K. Adele Hirsch

00:47 03 Jun 21

I give the great staff & great pizza five stars!!! They work so hard & they cook lovely food. We got to meet the owner while visiting to pay. However he's unwelcoming & rude. Greeted myself with my husband at the counter. He's fixing a prepaid phone (in the kitchen) with the sim card for gps tracking his delivery drivers. All while phone's ringing & the owner refused to answer phones when other customers had to be put on hold. We pay, wait in our vehicle, notice I'm missing an order & I messed my pie order up while ordering on the phone. I go back, by myself, in to explain my order. Their cashier was helping me order a new pie & trying to get my misplaced sweet peppers we ordered from a previous order. (My mistake on not communicating correctly in my first order.) The owner tells the cashier to "answer the phones & ignore her". When the same cashier was in the middle of fixing the missing peppers from my first order & ringing up the second order. All I wish for is the workers getting higher salaries & better respect. The owner & his Tesla can be rude outside of his own restaurant. If he's inside leave & don't get disrespected.

Justin Gittings

15:52 10 May 21

There's so many "meh" quality pizza places around that it can be difficult to weed out the good from the bad. If you're looking for great pizza look no further than "Sandy's Pizza", they've got the best pizza in the tri-state!I get sick of all those "bargain" pizzas from the big chain restaurants, that really aren't that good, but you settle for because of their internet specials. With Sandy's you get an excellent pizza cooked to perfection, loaded with delicious toppings. The sweet red peppers are a personal favorite! Staff is nice and friendly too!

Karen Peach

07:57 03 May 21

Best pizza and sandwiches around. Sweet red peppers are fabulous and staff is always friendly.

Terri Guisewite

22:54 02 May 21

Went to Sandy's tonight and the pizza was very good! Our waitress was very much an asset to this business (friendly, quick, and attentive) 👏 we will be back.

arnold beck

01:20 25 Apr 21

Great pizza. First time eating pizza here in 3 years. They need some help in kitchen. 25 min wait ontop of the 50 min wait they said it would be. Went to get pizza and the place only had 3 groups of people in the restaurant eating. Other than that, great experience.

Dale Johnson

23:38 12 Mar 21

It was great, good service and fast an I drove from Evansville to fort branch to get it and it is so good I will drive it one's or twist a month to buy food from there it's that good.

BillyToni Codynah

11:45 22 Feb 21

The food was awesome as always! The staff was great considering how many people showed up unexpectedly due to the basketball tournament. Always a great place to have large parties with a reservation.

STEVE ROBERTSON

02:30 04 Feb 21

Great place sure missed tracy not being there

Alice Trinkle

13:44 25 Dec 20

There pizza was so good ☺️. Very friendly service and very fast and clean. This place was awesome.

Susan Zenthofer

19:51 22 Dec 20

The young man that helpful. I really appreciate all that he done.

Bruce

17:33 08 Dec 20

Hands down the best pizza I've ever ate!!!! Sausage and jalapeños 10 inch and apple desert is highly recommended plus drivers they deliver to the truck stops and hotels!!!!!

Devan Wright (VonSpushin)

21:55 30 Nov 20

There thin crust pizza is hands down the best in the Tri-State!

Heather Luttrell

20:28 21 Sep 20

Best Pizza in Ft. Branch! Plus an added bonus, I paid cash and got a discount!

Team 9 of hearts Armstrong/Dugan

01:19 04 Sep 20

Super homey and family like!! Great place for sports teams and families!!

Scott Logan

03:14 24 Aug 20

Recent visit didn't go too good but pizza was good in the past. Hopefully this was a one off. The marinara dipping sauce and pizza sauce literally tasted and smelled like beer. Very friendly and helpful waitress though.

brad mayfield

02:59 19 Aug 20

Excellent pizza and a wonderful staff. The decor is very unique and fun to look over.

Kyle Brown

23:38 09 Aug 20

Ordered over the phone for pick up was given 30-35 minutes pizza was just coming out of the oven upon arrival which made the ride home and was still fresh customer service was excellent

Shawn Harper

01:37 02 Aug 20

We got the supreme with banana peppers. Excellent pizza!!!

Laura Murphy

00:28 02 Aug 20

It was awesome! Staff was great! Clean/great food!!

Mary Whitehead

02:11 13 Jul 20

Sandys was very busy the night we got pizza, so it took longer than usual, but always worth the wait. The pizza with Stromboli meat,pepperoni and sweet red peppers was great and the chicken cranberry salad was fantastic!!

Sheree Seib

21:54 30 May 20

Best pizza, our favorite place. Antiques in restaurant and has been a small business forever.Please go and support their reopening. Oh, and they have buffet days too!!

Alicia Jaye Phillips

02:54 15 Mar 20

I had the ham and cheese sandwich, it was delicious! A very unique restaurant, one of a kind! Train runs the track directly behind the restaurant, feel it rumble hear it blow!

Rachel Newton

01:16 02 Mar 20

To all my trucking friends. This place delivered to us at the Loves truckstop and they didn't disappoint! Although they forgot my garlic dipping sauce they were very prompt about bringing it to me. For our trouble they brought us 2 bottles of their root beer which is so delicious! Please support this place and you will not be disappointed. The pizza and wings we order was so good!

Wyatt Arvin

19:25 16 Feb 20

Great local pizza restaurant. The restaurant itself is decorated with nostalgic Americana themes. We came here for the Sunday buffet. Due to the smaller size of the restaurant, the selection of pizza was limited. What it lacked in variety, it made up for in quality and taste. Included in the adult buffet is even one beer or wine. They had dessert pizza (Apple) and soft serve ice cream. Definitely recommend.

Leigh Childers

01:17 12 Feb 20

Went for the buffet tonight. There was limited pizza available when we got there but after we sat down, a waitress asked how the buffet looked and if she could make us anything which I thought was great. I love the buffet here. It's a great price that includes, the pizza bar, pasta bar, salad bar, ice cream and drink.

robin Marriott

02:56 05 Jan 20

First time every there. Absolutely awesome food. Love the vintage atmosphere. Very friendly staff and homey. Prices very cheap! Will be goong back to try their buffet soon!

Angelia Phillips

18:11 02 Jan 20

Love me sometimes Sandy's Pizza! They make delicious vegan pizzas on request to add to their buffet!

Lacy Jacobs

23:18 08 Dec 19

I ordered chicken bacon ranch pizza and wings and it was all amazing. I had delivery and they was earlier than what they told me which was great too. Highley recomend this pizza place

Scoe Brown

04:25 08 Dec 19

I have Sandy pizza at least twice a week. I drive from Evansville Indiana just to come have it.The chicken bbq pizza is utterly delicious. I love it. The general manager is always nice and make you feel like you’re a guest and not jus a customer she goes beyond to make you feel welcome and you’re very satisfied before leaving.The staff is great as well....

Brittany Williams

14:15 18 Nov 19

Good food, great atmosphere and the GM and empoyees are very friendly! Highly recommend!!!

Roger Cooper

18:33 07 Nov 19

Love that sweet pepper pizza my lips are still flapping my eyebrows off!!!

Shawn Bayne

15:38 06 Nov 19

Sandys is one of my most favorite pizza place i have always loved the pizza and i loved working for them it was the best opportunity that i got and i loved every second of it if i was still working there i would always buy pizza almost every friday. point is its amazing

Kevin Marchal

19:38 03 Nov 19

I keep hearing how "it's not like it used to be... Well that might be right... Today it was better than ever... Service and food was excellent.

Karen Garrett

21:37 08 Sep 19

Always order my food before 3pm! Never go wrong if Kims working! Great Pizza, Strom and Spaghetti! Thanks Kim and the day shift crew! Had an awesome dinner!

Masta Nobu

18:37 27 Aug 19

It's good. Nothing over the top, but much better than other alternatives.

Carrie Ochs

00:51 12 Aug 19

Pizza is very good! Love the sweet red peppers! The combination is what we got it had a few too many olives for me. But my husband really likes them. The cheesey bread is very good we didnt get it before our meal which was kind of disappointing. But it was delicious. We was here on a Sunday evening and they had 2 large parties in the back and they could have used another waitress. But overall it was a good place to eat.

Ricky Spanish

01:52 02 Aug 19

It's pizza, what more do you want? Storms? Yep. Clouds? Yep. Rain? All here. They even have an ancient eldritch horror in the parking lot that greets you. 10/10 will summon again.

Jay Ward

21:25 01 Aug 19

Awesome pizza! Great staff! You are definitely and asset to Toyota! Repeat customer for over 16 years.

S Phillips

04:46 14 Jun 19

Awesome pizza with cracker style crust. Staff is always nice and attentive and the interior is always clean and fun to look at with all of the Coca-Cola memorabilia. Also, they have Sprecher root beer on tap which is a huge plus.

Brianne Ferguson

02:55 09 Jun 19

Our family of 21 ate here tonight. Many were small children. All of us enjoyed the food!

Drew Robbins

20:18 02 May 19

If you like red bell peppers be sure to get them on your pizza! They are sweet and add a unique flavor to whatever pizza you get. Nostalgic environment.

Michael Sampson

13:29 13 Apr 19

Great atmosphere and even greater pizza. I ordered the all meat with the "sweet reds" (red peppers) and it was delicious. The crust was thin and crispy and the pizza was baked to perfection. Being from out of town and eating our local pizza, this is definitely a nice change from our usual pizza. Sandy's is a place you should give a try, because you'll come back often. Oh, and our server was excellent too. Her recommendations for the pizzas we ordered made a huge difference.

Andrew Nikirk

19:31 30 Mar 19

Fantastic pizza, I usually only get down there 1 time a year but when I do I always go to Sandy's. The pizza is great and I buy a jar of the red sweet peppers everytime to put on other restaurants pizza.

Jonathan Hall

20:53 28 Mar 19

Great food, fresh and hot. friendly service and fast, the buffet is amazing, great atmosphere love the antiques and fair prices, I highly recommend them

chad schoening

15:02 05 Mar 19

By far the best pizza in the area. Take out is much better than the buffet. The all meat pizza is awesome. I last ate there 4 years ago and still have not found better pizza anywhere else.

Kyle Carner

02:26 05 Mar 19

Just had a pizza delivered and it's amazing thank you guys so much for the short waiting time and great service!!!

Valerie Nadalini

01:42 15 Feb 19

Worth the wait! Great pizza and friendly staff, definitely a favorite if you're looking for the local restaurant.

Michael Huther

15:21 09 Feb 19

Great pizza and a really cool atmosphere. Friendly staff and service is pretty quick.

Darren Smelser

15:39 01 Feb 19

One of the best pizza joints in Southetn Indiana, or anywhere for that matter. Amd leftovers are just as good the next day!

Donna Wallace

00:40 02 Jan 19

They were busy as can be but the service was still great and everyone was friendly! They have the best pizza and sides ever! If you want great food and a great hometown atmosphere Sandys is the place to go!

Holly Walden

18:15 24 Nov 18

Always delicious. Buffet is fair price for pizza bread dessert salad bar and pasta bar eith Texas toast. My favorite weekend spot

Michele Bruce

04:43 14 Nov 18

The particular pizza sauce they use is the exact taste I love. Sweet red peppers are like candy. The service is professional and the people are warm and friendly. The thing that stands out with this establishment is the decor and atmosphere. I would live inside it if I could!

Robert Hopkins

14:28 14 Oct 18

Unique interior...there's vintage things all over the walls and ceiling. Kids of all ages love the ice cream machine...self-served. Salad bar is great. Daily lunch buffet. Dinner buffet Tues and Wed nights. Id say most people develope a craving for their sweet red peppers. Barbecue Chicken pizza without the jalapeños is my favorite. Give this place a try.

Lori Holder

19:51 22 Sep 18

Great place to eat. We ate off the buffet and they made fresh pizza for us

Carmen Scott

07:57 12 Aug 18

Great pizza and pasta. Fast service, freindly people, and interesting decor. Decent prices also. Highly recommended.

Jon Schrage

15:01 11 Jul 18

I love the pizza here. Make sure that you order one with the sweet red peppers... They are amazing.

Dan Knox

09:32 06 Jul 18

The best lunch pizza buffet ever!! Pizza was fresh, delicious and fast service!! Great atmosphere too. When you go try the the root beer in the barrel! The best root beer you will have.

Kimberley Phillippe

14:57 28 Jun 18

Amazing pizzas. We had a small combination pizza, 2 salad bars and 2 drinks for about $20.

April Helfert

18:44 12 Jun 18

Great pizza and service. I love that you have Diet Mt. Dew

Shannyn Richardville

14:27 12 Jun 18

The people there are super. The food is amazing and worth the money. Would very much recommend this place to eat at.

Kathy Liden

12:26 03 Jun 18

Best pizza in this area. Hate the wait on the line though, but it's worth it Strombolis are spectacular, I tried other one down the road from them and was sick for a week. Wont leave Sandys again

Mark Schmitz

12:41 26 May 18

Local favorite. Great atmosphere. Good pizza etc

Daniel Sigler

01:52 14 May 18

Best pizza in the area with fun & homey decor. If you are in the area a must go.

Brenna Kelley

22:27 31 Mar 18

We got there with only an hour left for the buffet and 4 hungry girls. They asked what the girls wanted and made it for them. Salad bar was nice with fresh veggies.

Christopher Lance Shell

22:38 05 Mar 18

I think their crust could be better but their toppings are awesome. They have a salad bar thats included as well as on tap root beer and ice cream. And love the atmosphere

Joey Brines

00:33 24 Feb 18

The food and the service was great. Great atmosphere.

Benjamin Bush

17:53 14 Feb 18

Pizza is awesome. The fact that they don't keep fresh pizzas coming out on the buffet makes it not worth the drive for us. I understand food cost but gas is expensive and time is priceless. I heard about there pizza a lot. Finally had it for lunch 4 days in two weeks. The Root beer is sooo good tho

Fiona Jarvis

15:33 31 Dec 17

Great service and best pizza ! I Always enjoy coming here with family when i visit for the holidays .

Jennifer Wilder

01:00 31 Dec 17

Best pizza in the Tri-State area! We eat here every time we visit our family in Owensville. The inside is cute with old signs and lots of broken clocks. We love the crust and the sweet red peppers are delicious!

Chris Wilkerson

15:17 17 Dec 17

Pizza was good and the staff was friendly. Takes a little while to get your food but worth the wait.

Nicole Stevenson

22:44 22 Sep 17

The atmosphere is great and food I'd phenomenal! Would definitely recommend this nice down home pizza joint!

Revive Harpers

00:03 21 Sep 17

I always enjoy going to Sandy's. They have a great atmosphere. They also make some of the best pizza's and strom's in my area.

Nathan Pfeffer

17:27 05 Sep 17

Nice local restaurant with a good atmosphere and delicious pizza.

Matthew Bartsch

20:50 23 Aug 17

Have ate here several times and it is always a clean fun environment. Love all the nostalgia hanging all over the place and of course the pizza pies and other food are the best around. Keep up the great food!!

Theresa Bunch

23:04 16 Jul 17

Fun family pizza place. Great buffet, we will definitely be stopping in on our next trip to the area.

Jon Baker

17:26 14 Jul 17

Always love the buffet, real pizza just like you would order, not cheap skimpy versions

Eric Thompson

23:01 06 Jul 17

Helpful staff with unique pizza. They will make whatever you would like on buffet nights. Quality ingredients.

Chris Overton

22:21 04 Jul 17

Best pizza ever. Roasted red peppers are great. My favorite pizza on the planet.

Keevin Biggs

04:07 31 Mar 17

Nice Local Pizza Place--Always very busy--they have buffets, and you can order from a large menu, along with free refills and ice cream. It is a nearby, very good local pizza place. Don't miss their pizza with the cherry peppers!

Allen E

20:49 11 Mar 17

Today I tried the Sunday buffet. Great ice cream and selection of pizza. I also enjoyed the root beer that they had on tap. Though the food was good I did have a issue locating the correct public entrance to the building. After that I did not find a sign posted stating if I should wait to be seated or even be greeted before begining the buffet. Once I approached a employee they were friendly and took care of me. I enjoyed the atmosphere with multiple TV's that provided different sport stations. I'd suggest this local brand over a national chain.

bryan holzappel

22:55 06 Mar 17

Good pizza! Love the sweet red peppers! The root beer here is wonderful!

Brian Mitchell

18:13 26 Feb 17

Amazing pizza. Sausage and sweet red peppers is probably my favorite. Kind staff. Buffet style service with a friendly happy attitude. Lots of neat stuff to look at in this place.

See All Reviews Write a review